Skip to main content

Election Petition: Aniekan Umanah Floors Ekon At Tribunal



The National and State House of Assembly Election Tribunal, sitting in Uyo, the Akwa Ibom State Capital, today, September 11, 2019 upheld the victory of Hon. Aniekan Umanah as the winner of the February 23 elections as member, representing Abak/Etim Ekpo/Ika Federal Constituency.

The Petitoners, The All Progressives Congress and Hon Emmanuel Ekon had challenged the election of Hon. Aniekan Umanah on two grounds to wit:

1) That the election and return of the 1st Respondent, Hon. Aniekan Umanah is invalid by reason of substantial non-compliance

2) That the 1st Respondent, Hon. Aniekan Umanah was not duly elected by the majority of lawful votes cast at the elections.

The Petitioners consequent on the foregoing grounds prayed the court to cancel the elections same being held, not in compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Act, nullify the certificate issued to the 1st Respondent as the winner of the February 23 elections or in the alternative, declare the 1st Petitioner, Mr Emmanuel Ekon, as the winner of the said elections.

The court first gave her ruling on a motion filed by the petitioner seeking to foreclose the Respondents from defending the case on grounds that the Respondents made a typographical slip on the process. The court held that since the court had already determined a motion on that subject by dismissing the petitioner's application in July 9, 2019, the court could not as now sought by the Petitioner sit on appeal over its decision. The court therefore dismissed the motion of the petitioner and held that the Respondents had a right to defend the case and that they had done so within the limits of the law.

On the merit of the case, the court, after a review of the evidence given by the witnesses and all documents before the court held that the Petitioners did not prove non-compliance with the Electoral Act and further that the non-compliance, assuming the tribunal were to even consider that such was established in any little way, was not sufficient non-compliance such as could substantially affect the results of the elections.

The court held that the evidence of all the eleven witnesses of the Petitioners were insufficient to prove substantial non-compliance which is the only grounds that could lead the court to decide in favour of the Petitioner. The court held that:

"Proving non-compliance would require a unit by unit prove by the petitioner... consequently, the Petitioner's attempt to use 11 polling unit agents to establish non-compliance in an election that covered over 200 polling units could achieve anything but never a proof for substantial non-compliance with the provisions of the Act".

The Petitioners having failed to prove substantial non-compliance, corrupt practices or that the 1st Respondent did not win by majority of lawful votes cast at the elections, the court consequently dismissed the case and ordered cost of 50,000 naira each in favour of the 1st and 2nd Respondents.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

AKHA Defers Giving Resolution To Extend Transition Committees..mandates Committee to verify performance of councils

  By Asuquo Edem Akwa Ibom State House of Assembly today put off giving the governor a resolution to extend the stay of Transition Committees across the State. The State governor who communicated his request for the House Resolution dated 6th May 2024 drawing strength from Section 5 sub 2 of the Local Government Administration Law pleaded with the lawmakers to heed to giving the resolution to extend the tenure of Transition Councils as the Commission responsible for conducting elections require an extended time frame. The motion to receive the letter for deliberation was moved by the member representing Ikono Rt. Hon. Asuquo Nana and was seconded by the member representing Ika State Constituency, Rt. Hon. Mfon Idung. However the Speaker, Rt. Hon. Udeme Otong stated that the Resolution as requested by the governor can't be given today as the House needs to accertain if the Transition Committees are deserving of an extension taking into consideration that they have served for six mon...

Reasons Moses Essien Dumped YPP

  By Asuquo Edem It's no longer news that the member representing Ibiono Ibom State Constituency, Hon. Moses Essien has parted ways with the Young Progressive Party(YPP) pitching tents with the ruling People's Democratic Party (PDP). The lawmaker who announced his defection to the PDP today during Plenary at the House of Assembly stated among other reasons his decision to move camp owing to the division amongst the leadership of YPP in the State. In his words: " I write to notify the Speaker and members of the People's Democratic party ( PDP ) in the Assembly of the formal resignation of my membership from the Young Progressive Party (YPP) to People's Democratic Party (PDP). The reason for this action is based on the division within the YPP leadership in Akwa Ibom State, where the 2023 Governorship candidate of the YPP, the state chairman of the party and the State officers including chapter officers of the party and stalwarts of the party decamp to the All Progres...

Akwa Ibom Thrown Into Mourning As Gov Umo Eno Loses Wife To Death

  Akwa Ibom State has been thrown into deep mourning and grief as the wife of the State governor has passed away. In a Press Release signed by the Commissioner for Information, Comrade Ini Ememobong read in part.. "Iis with heavy hearts that we announce the passing of the Wife of the Executive Governor of Akwa Ibom State, Her Excellency, Pastor Mrs. Patience Umo Eno, following an  illness. She passed away peacefully at the hospital, on 26th September, 2024, in the presence of her family. The family submits to the will of the Almighty and asks for the prayers and support of kind-hearted individuals during this difficult time. Further details will be provided by the family as necessary. In the meantime, the family kindly requests privacy as they mourn their beloved wife, mother and grandmother. His Excellency, the Governor, Pastor Umo Eno appreciates all who have stood by the first family in this period and assures all the citizens that despite this huge personal loss, his commi...